Saturday April 16, 2011 by Ryan Fernandez
A good bowl of soup is one that makes for an holistic experience, one where the importance of every ingredient comes into play. We sampled similar noodle dishes at two different Chinese restaurants to see what exactly set each apart.
As a sort of control group I felt I should choose the kind of restaurant that's just your average Chinese noodles type of place, so I wandered in to Liu Xiang Yuan Restaurant in San Gabriel, CA. This area has a high concentration of places like this.. the plaza where it is located houses five of them.
Liu Xiang Yuan Restaurant 704 W. Las Tunas Dr Ste 5 San Gabriel, CA 91776
The Fried pork ribs with noodle soup was nothing special here, with some carrots and bok choy rounding out this average offering. No complaints, it was served piping hot, but it wasn't quite anything to remember.
A look at a similar dish at Xi'an Famous Foods in New York's Chinatown, however, takes us completely to the other side of the pork noodle soup spectrum. A place once documented by Anthony Bourdain, Xi'an Famous Foods actually holds quite a reputation among New York foodies.
Xi'an Famous Foods 81 Saint Marks Place New York, NY 10003
All the noodles here are handmade, but that's not the only thing that makes the pork noodles in soup here excellent.
The tangy, colorful broth was quite the standout in this dish, and the green onions and garnish really put this bowl of soup over the top.
A great dish is not only the sum of its ingredients but the harmony amongst them as well. Liu Xiang Yuan and Xi'an Famous Foods may have both been serving pork noodle soup for quite some length of time, but it is obvious that one of them takes great care in trying to get the mixture of ingredients just right. It's really more than just one aspect of the dish that makes it whole.
MenuGem Featured Stories Jeans and Masks
The MenuGem Standard Mask - Discover What's Next S02E01
Shop with Confidence
What You Need
Rest Assured: Hand Sanitizer, Masks and More
MenuGem in Illinois Times and on WMAY
New Products on MenuGem Springfield and The MenuGem Web Store
Introducing MenuGem Springfield!
We're Here for You
How to Earn Gems on MenuGem
Online Ordering in Chicago
How to Set Up Online Ordering for Your Restaurant
Order from Baba Pita!
Beverly Hills, De-Mystified: Scarpetta
Tastes of Tokyo: Roku-Michi in Roppongi Hills
Sushi Gen Stays Above the Cut
Rustic Italian Meets Hipster Chic at Reno Chicago
A Quick Bite at Firenze Osteria
Testarossa Winery is Serious About Its Soils
5 Years of Craft Los Angeles
Surf and Turf for Lunch at Wakasaya
Reforming Danishes at Amandine Patisserie
Through the Fog
Pad Se Ew Showdown